Commentary
One of the greatest challenges is transforming educational theories into effective practices in the classroom. On one hand it is wonderful and necessary to strive to introduce concepts of peace and self exploration into schools. On the other hand is the classroom reality – teachers are already burdened with the challenge of implementing prescribed curriculum and teaching students what they need to know for examinations. There are numerous examples worldwide of teachers who have been introduced to student centered pedagogies yet are not implementing them. We need to look at why these gaps exist between theory and practice.
While they strive to be universal, some of the theories and ideas presented in A New Global Education are very distant from the educational realities worldwide. What A New Global Education calls for is a paradigm shift. I believe that a simple shift in outlook and purposes to the big picture behind why we are educating can be used to inspire and guide educators worldwide. Through passion, innovation, dedication, inspiration and providing a living example, educators have and will be able to change the role of education in our world.
I introduce here schools and other initiatives that have succeeded in implementing holistic and child centered approaches to education. Some of these schools and initiatives are in developing countries and some are here in the West. What I have here is just a smattering of educational initiatives that stand out to me as an inspiration of what education could be.
Riane
Eisler (2005:49), the creator of Partnership Education, has posed some
wonderful questions about the inner workings of schools. One challenge is that theory can often
be abstracted from practice and reality.
These questions serve as a guide when looking at participatory and
student centered models of education.
- Are young people
treated with caring and respect?
- Do teachers act as
primarily lesson dispensers and controllers, or more as mentors and
facilitators?
- Are students
learning to work together or must the continuously compete with one
another?
- Are they offered
the opportunity for self directed learning?
- Is education
merely a matter of teachers inserting information into young people’s
minds, or are students and teachers partners in a meaningful adventure of
exploration and learning?
- Do teachers and staff participate in school decision-making and rule making?
- Does the curriculum effectively teach students not only basic academic and vocational skills but also the life skills they need to be competent and caring citizens, workers and community members?
Living
Examples
Aurobindo: Education
at Auroville
http://www.auroville.org/education.htm
Auroville
is an international intentional community recognized by UNESCO in South India
based on Aurobindo’s vision and principles. The aim of Auroville was to create a universal town where
men and women of all countries are able to live in peace and progressive
harmony, above all creeds, all politics and all nationalities. Much devotion is given to education at
Auroville. A number of educational facilities exist for both international
children and local village children, often in a mixed environment. Six schools from primary through high
school exist for the children Auroville residents and seven for local Tamil children. The aim, while working in close
collaboration with the existing government educational structure, is to provide
value-oriented education in an atmosphere of simplicity, beauty, joy and
harmony wherein the children can develop naturally. Auroville has created a new model of international education
by educating local village children and foreign children in the same
classroom. The schools here have
truly succeeded in fostering a sense of international cooperation and
understanding.
Brockwood Park School,
England (Krishnamurti)
http://www.brockwood.org.uk/intro/index.htm
“At
Brockwood Park School we are committed to educating young people to meet life
as a whole. Academic excellence is absolutely necessary, but equal importance
is given to an ongoing inquiry into the way we live our daily lives. Many of
the difficulties in today's world are the outcome of attitudes and beliefs that
education for our times needs to examine.
In the secure and friendly surroundings of Brockwood Park, students are
encouraged to reflect on their own thoughts, feelings and actions and on those
of others. Brockwood offers a setting where students and staff can learn to
live and work together harmoniously and intelligently.”
CARE Pakistan
http://www.carepakistan.org/care/index.html
CARE is a progressive
education endeavor in Pakistan. Today, CARE educates 86,000 children in a total
of 171 CARE adopted schools.
City Montessori
School, Lucknow India
CMS is the world’s largest Montessori school with
over 30,000 students. They
received UNESCO’s prize for peace education in 2002. The nonprofit private school was opened in by Dr. and Mrs.
Jagdish Gandhi 1959 with five students.
Devout Gandhians, the couple wanted the school to be an instrument for
imparting values of universal brotherhood and the cultivation of virtues. CMS
creates a climate of encouragement to facilitate all-around development of
every child and trains them in high moral and ethical values. CMS believes that ordinary children can
develop in extraordinary ways when provided the right environment, motivation,
and care.
Findhorn Foundation
& Community
http://www.findhorn.org/home_new.php
The
Findhorn Community was founded in 1962 in Scotland. Today the Findhorn
Foundation is the central educational and organizational heart of a widely
diversified community of several hundred people, spanning dozens of holistic
businesses and initiatives, all linked by a shared positive vision for humanity
and the earth, and a commitment to the deep and practical non-doctrinal
spirituality established in the Findhorn Community by its founders. Its work is
based on the values of planetary service, co-creation with nature and
attunement to the divinity within all beings. “We believe that humanity is
engaged in an evolutionary expansion of consciousness, and seek to develop new
ways of living infused with spiritual values. We have no formal creed or
doctrine. We recognise and honour all the world's major religions as the many
paths to knowing our own inner divinity”.
Global Education
Associates
GEA's mission is to
advance global systems that will secure ecological integrity, peace, human
rights, economic and social well-being, and democratic participation, with
special care to include the voices and perspectives of poor and marginalized
people and of diverse cultural and religious traditions.
The Goldie Hawn Bright
Light Foundation
http://www.brightlightfoundation.net/greetings.html
The goal of the Bright
Light foundation is to help young people create and live more compassionate,
responsible and joyful lives. The foundation works in three areas: classroom
education with teachers, community education with parents, and in healthcare
institutions. The mission of the
foundation is to untie scientists and educators to develop tools that improve
students’ attention skills for learning and social-emotional competence.
Hyde Schools
The
philosophy of the Hyde schools is that every student, every parent, and every
teacher is meant to connect with a deep and special purpose in life. At Hyde, character development is the key to
unlocking that purpose. The Hyde
school was founded by Joseph Gauld, a highly regarded mathematics teacher, who
was inspired to open a unique school because he believed that the existing
educational system was overly focused on student achievement rather than
character. The school began with a focus on Five Words: Courage, Integrity,
Leadership, Curiosity, and Concern, and the cardinal principle that every
individual was born with a unique potential that defines a destiny. Hyde School
is a unique 9–12 college preparatory boarding school, and a national
leader in character education. Hyde has two private school campuses in the
Northeast US and three public charter schools.
InnerKids Foundation
Founded
in 2001, InnerKids is a national leader in teaching
Mindful Awareness to children in pre-K through middle school. Mindful Awareness
is a state of present attention in which one observes thoughts, feelings,
emotions and events at the moment they occur without reacting to them in an
automatic or habitual way. InnerKids’ Mindful
Awareness activities take into account children’s developmental differences,
train focused attention and awareness, and acknowledge clarity and compassion
as part of the process of becoming more attentive and aware.
Oak Grove School,
California (Krishnamurti)
http://www.oakgroveschool.com/
Oak
Grove School offers innovative early
childhood, elementary,
junior high
school programs, a college-preparatory high school,
and a family-style boarding program all nourished by the educational vision of
its founder, philosopher and educator J. Krishnamurti. Small classes in a
natural environment are guided by experienced teachers who encourage discovery
and inquiry while supporting exceptional academic, creative and personal
growth.
Peace Education Center
– Teachers College – Columbia University
http://www.tc.edu/PeaceEd/spiritethic/index.htm
Shikshantar – The
People’s Institute for Rethinking Education and Development – Udaipur,
Rajasthan, India
http://www.swaraj.org/shikshantar/
Shikshantar
is “an applied research institute dedicated to catalyzing radical systemic
transformation of education in order to facilitate Swaraj-development
throughout India”. Swaraj is based
on Gandhi’s concept of self rule which centers on self sustainability.
Shikshantar uses the city Udaipur as a learning city and challenges us to
rethink the meaning of education and development.
Sri Aurobindo
International Centre of Education
http://www.sriaurobindosociety.org.in/subnav/educentr.htm
The Sri Aurobindo International Centre of Education was Aurobindo’s first major experiment in education. Founded 1952 in Pondicherry India, the school has been open to students from around the world since its inception. The school currently serves 1200 students from kindergarten through the university level. It is one of the most respected schools in the region. Pupils pay no fees at the Centre of Education - once admitted, the education is free.
The
school blends Aurobindo’s philosophies with the British model of education. The
format of the Centre of Education is based on Aurobindo’s concepts of Free
Progress and integral education. The school strives to organize an environment
and an atmosphere affording inspiration and facilities for the exercise and
development of the five essential aspects of personality: the physical, the
vital, the mental, the psychic and the spiritual. The aim of the school is to help the child, as he reaches
adolescence with its accompanying growth in awareness and maturity, to assume
more responsibility for educating himself, so that he may find within himself
the lines of his own development.
Close observation and a continuous assessment of the child’s activities,
as well as individual contact between teacher and student, eliminate the necessity
of using examinations as a tool to evaluate progress. The Centre of Education emphasizes the unity of all
knowledge and to attempts to bring humanities and science closer together into
a real sense of unity for the benefit of both.
Sudbury Valley School
Sudbury
Valley School and its affiliated schools provide a setting in which students
are independent, are trusted, and are treated as responsible people; and a
community in which students are exposed to the complexities of life in the
framework of a participatory democracy.
Students of all ages determine what they will do, as well as when, how,
and where they will do it. This freedom is at the heart of the school. Sudbury schools are found throughout
the United States and worldwide.
Third Millennium
Foundation
http://www.seedsoftolerance.org/initiative_tmf_center.html
International Center for
Tolerence Education: A Do Tank for Social Entrepreneurs
University for Peace
Headquartered
in Costa Rica, the United Nations-mandated University for Peace was established
in December 1980. The mission of
the University of Peace is to “provide
humanity with an international institution of higher education for peace with
the aim of promoting among all human beings the spirit of understanding,
tolerance and peaceful coexistence, to stimulate cooperation among peoples and
to help lessen obstacles and threats to world peace and progress, in keeping
with the noble aspirations proclaimed in the Charter of the United Nations”.
The university focuses its rigorous academic program on the
fundamental causes of conflict through a multidisciplinary,
multicultural-oriented approach.
US Institute for Peace
– Education Sector
http://www.usip.org/ed/index.html
The Education program of the United States Institute of Peace seeks to address the needs of educators, students, scholars, international affairs practitioners, and the public to understand the complexities of international conflicts.
Resources
Borg, Carmel and Mayo, Peter. (2006). Learning and social difference: challenges for public education and critical pedagogy. Boulder: Paradigm Publishers.
Musil, Caryn McTighe. (2006). Assessing global learning: matching good intentions with good practice. Washington, DC: Association of American Colleges and Universities.
Noddings, N. (1992) The Challenge To Care In Schools: An Alternative Approach to Education, Teachers College Press, Columbia University, New York.
UNESCO. (2002). Best Practices on Non-Violent Conflict Resolution in & out of school: Some Examples. Paris, France: Antonella Verdiani, ed.
UNESCO. (1997). Thinkers in Education: Studies in Comparative Education Series. Paris: UNESCO Publishing. http://www.ibe.unesco.org/publications/thinkers.htm.
Wonderful resource highlighting 100 educational thinkers profiled.